❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ (5/5) Tested by Cass — ~8 hrs · One 20–22" braid
Divide the dough into three equal ropes, braid them into one long three-strand braid, and bake on a parchment-lined sheet pan. Optional: pinch off a small piece for a flattened boule that bakes beside it as punctuation — someone gets to claim it whole. Soft tender interior, glossy oil-brushed top, parmesan-and-rosemary crown. Pulls apart along the braid joints into rustic chunks. Designed to live in the middle of the table next to pasta or soup.
Ingredients
Dough
Pan, Topping & Finish
Method
Notes
Bake it straight, not coiled. A straight braid on a sheet pan has far more exposed surface than a coiled wreath in a round pan, so it colours and cooks faster — 18–22 minutes rather than 22–25. Watch the colour and use internal temp; don't trust the clock.
Do the second rise on the pan you'll bake on. Moving a risen braid is genuinely risky.
Why flatten the boule. A solid golf-ball lump has a low surface-area-to-volume ratio and would still be doughy in the middle when the braid is done. Flattened to ¾" it cooks at the same rate, and still rises into a soft dome.
KitchenAid: never above speed 2 for bread dough. The manual is explicit — higher speeds can burn out the motor or strip the gear. Speed 1 to combine, speed 2 to knead. Stop and scrape the sides once if the dough creeps up.
Dough climbing the hook and balling at the top instead of slapping the sides means it's too dry — drizzle in 1 tbsp warm water with the motor running. Still a sticky puddle at 5 minutes? Give it 2 more. Gluten takes time. Don't add flour unless it's still puddly at 8 minutes total, which it won't be.
If a rope tears while rolling: pinch it back together, rest 5 minutes covered, re-roll. It just needed a break. Don't add flour — that's how you get a dry rope.
Sloppy braid doesn't matter. Once it rises and bakes the lines soften and read as rustic artisan twist regardless. Aim for "recognisable three-strand", not "perfect". The parmesan, oil and rosemary hide a multitude of sins.
Pan choice: a thin cookie tray runs hotter on the bottom, so watch for over-browning underneath. A rimmed half-sheet is the safer default. Parchment handles release either way.
Cup measurements: the water is the one that matters — it lands between 1⅓ and 1½ cups, so scant 1½ cups gets you there. Weigh it if you can; 1 ml = 1 g. A packet of instant yeast is already 2¼ tsp / 7 g, so just tip the whole thing in.
Hand-knead fallback: mix wet into dry with a wooden spoon until shaggy, turn onto a floured bench, knead 5 minutes — push, fold, quarter-turn, repeat. Same finish: soft, smooth, slightly tacky.